Wonderful service from start to finish.
Getting probation right sets the tone for performance, culture and risk management in the workplace. A fair, structured probationary process helps new starters understand what is expected of them, gives them a real opportunity to succeed, and gives employers clearer options if things aren't working out. With unfair dismissal protection reducing from two years to six months, an employee’s probationary period will become one of the most important parts of the employee’s engagement.
In this article, we explain what a probationary period is, how employers can run a fair process, why documentation matters, and the key legal risks around length of service and timing.
What is a probationary period?
A probationary period is a contractual or policy tool that allows you to assess whether someone is suitable for their role during an initial period. Probation is commonly used when an employee first starts a role, or when an existing employee moves into a different area of work.
Employers should set out the probation length, standards and consequences of non-completion in contracts or policies, and apply them consistently. Managed properly, probationary periods can be a powerful way to assess whether someone is right for the role, while giving you options if they aren’t the right fit.
How should employers run a fair probationary process?
Start by setting clear expectations from day one. Explain the standards, targets and behaviours required for the role, and give practical examples of what good performance looks like.
Use regular touchpoints, including early, mid-point and end-of-probation reviews, with more frequent check-ins where concerns arise. Do not save feedback for the end of the process. Raise concerns promptly so the employee has a fair chance to respond and improve. If an employee is surprised that they have failed their probationary period, this may suggest that they have not had meaningful probation reviews.
Documentation: Why is it so important?
Comprehensive documentation underpins a fair and effective probation process. Regular touchpoints and check-ins, supported by contact between meetings, help ensure concerns are raised promptly, and the employee is told without delay if conduct or performance is not suitable. Managers should keep clear, contemporaneous records. These can be both the best defence and the best management tool.
Keep notes of meetings, objectives, feedback given and received, support offered, warnings and decisions. Confirm key points in writing after each touchpoint, with clear next steps and deadlines. At the end of the process, issue a clear outcome letter confirming whether probation has been passed, extended or failed, with reasons and the effective date. Poor documentation can lead to misunderstandings, inconsistency, weaker decision-making and increased dismissal risk.
Unfair dismissal: the legal position
Unfair dismissal risk turns on the employee’s qualifying service and when employment legally ends, known as the effective date of termination (EDT). From 1 January 2027, the qualifying period for ordinary unfair dismissal will reduce to six months, down from two years.
The EDT matters because it is the point at which employment ends for statutory purposes. Depending on the notice period, it can push an employee over the qualifying threshold. If you pay in lieu of notice, the EDT is usually the termination date you give in the PILON letter. If you give notice to be worked, statutory or contractual notice may mean employment continues long enough to go over the six-month period, particularly if notice is given close to the end of that period.
Time meetings and letters carefully, and double-check whether statutory minimum notice would extend the EDT beyond the unfair dismissal point, even if you rely on shorter contractual notice.
What could employers do now?
Here are practical steps employers can take to build a fair and consistent probation process.
- Build a probation framework: Set standard review points, documentation templates and manager guidance.
- Set day-one objectives: Issue written, measurable goals and role-specific examples of good performance.
- Run structured reviews: Hold early, mid-point and end-of-probation reviews, escalating to weekly check-ins if concerns arise.
- Provide support: Log training, coaching, mentoring and any reasonable adjustments agreed.
- Decide and confirm outcomes: Confirm probation, extend it with objectives and dates, or end employment, all in writing.
What are the risks of getting this wrong?
A poor process can create legal, financial and cultural exposure.
- Unfair dismissal exposure: Qualifying employees may claim unfair dismissal and challenge reasonableness and procedure
. - Discrimination and whistleblowing: Claims can arise regardless of service if treatment links to protected characteristics or protected disclosures.
- Breach of contract/wrongful dismissal: Failure to follow notice, PILON or contractual procedures can trigger damages.
Summary
A fair probationary process is structured, documented and supportive. Set clear expectations early, give meaningful feedback and support, and record every step. Keep a close eye on length of service and the EDT when making timing decisions.
By following a consistent framework and maintaining a robust audit trail, you will give new starters the best chance to succeed and protect your organisation if termination becomes necessary.
Further Advice
If you need advice on managing probation periods or any other employment law matter, our Employment Peace of Mind team is here to help. Our Document Audit Team can also help review and draft workplace policies.
For further guidance, contact our Employment Team on 023 8071 7717 or email employment@warnergoodman.co.uk.